6 Dijon Mustard Substitutes to Give Your Dish a Certain “Je Ne Sais Quoi”. Instead, rely on the wisdom of the food experts over at A Couple Cooks and reach for one of these preferred kinds when you’re in need of a Dijon substitute. Although mayonnaise is lacking in both the complexity and subtle spice that Dijon delivers, it does have a similarly smooth consistency and is comparable in terms of acidity, too. Horseradish sauce is not the same as horseradish paste, as this one usually contains other ingredients, like vinegar, sugar, and salt. When she isn’t busy working, you can find her running with her dog Milo or reading a book in the sun. If you want a milder horseradish paste, make sure to add the vinegar as soon as possible. However, Japanese wasabi comes from a similar root and has a milder sharpness to it. Still, this recipe from the New York Times produces a delicious homemade Dijon-style mustard, so it’s worth filing away as a future DIY endeavor. That said, prepared horseradish holds up well as a substitute in most any recipe when used in the recommended proportions. RELATED: Need a Substitute for Vegetable Oil? 3. This DIY mustard is a cinch to make and can be used as a 1:1 swap in sauces, dressings and marinades. You can substitute horseradish for the same amount of black radish. This pungent condiment comes from the white root known as horseradish. Horseradish is popular in sauces like mustard or mayonnaise, but can also be added to cocktails, like the famous Bloody Mary. Here are some more acceptable swaps, courtesy of David Joachim, author of The Food Substitution Bible. There are many mustard varieties on the market and each one has its own unique flavor profile, but they do all have something in common: They’re all made with a combination of mustard seeds and a diluting agent like water, wine or vinegar. Brown mustard will add a peppery pungent taste that can mimic horseradish in things like prime rib, for Passover dishes, and even in certain drinks. These are the steps to follow: If you want to try a different flavor or can’t find this ingredient anywhere, then these horseradish substitutes are perfect for you: The flavor of wasabi is almost identical to horseradish, and some people refer to it as the “Japanese horseradish.”. If you want, you can add it to your cream and cocktail sauces, and use it as a dip. This ingredient is white inside and crispy, and the flavor is hot and sharp. While this is a completely different flavor, in certain cases you can use your favorite hot sauce in place of horseradish when you cook. Another good swap is spicy brown mustard but as the name suggests, this stuff has some extra heat that Dijon does not. Black Radish. No, these two are very different roots, though they share similar flavor and aroma. All rights reserved. (Sorry, yellow.) Good news: You can still find a suitable Dijon substitute, even if you don’t have any of the above options in your fridge. When using mayo in place of mustard, don’t overdo it: Use ⅓ the amount the recipe requires. However, keep in mind that this option brings its aroma too, so you don’t want to overdo it. Although stone ground mustard has a coarser texture than Dijon, most prepared versions of the stuff are made in the style of Dijon mustard and are thus very similar in flavor. You can find this sauce near the condiments section at the grocery store, but keep in mind that it is also not the same as horseradish mustard or mayonnaise. You can peel the radish for a milder flavor, but keep the skin if you want more heat. For example, 1 teaspoon of mayo can take the place of 1 tablespoon of mustard. Sign up for PureWow to get more ideas like these (It’s free!). If you want to prepare your horseradish at home, you need a blender or food processor, a peeler, and a knife. When you eat too much horseradish, you can experience an upset stomach, nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting. To achieve a similar amount of flavor, you will need about double the amount of ginger. People tend to consume radishes whole, but horseradish should be grated or ground. Sign up for PureWow to get more daily discoveries sent straight to your inbox. © 2010-2020 Wow Media Products, Inc doing business as PureWow. Add ginger to your Bloody Mary, stir-fry, cream and cocktail sauces, and fish dishes. That said, as long as you can handle some extra spice in your food, this mustard works well as a Dijon substitute and can be used in equal proportion in any recipe. Are what Give the mustard family, but can also be added to cocktails, like the famous Bloody.. Prime rib, sauces, and vomiting so you don ’ t worry in many recipes sandwich. The sun but it can work well when you prepare a cocktail an excellent substitute for Dijon own Dijon an... T already well-stocked with the stuff, don ’ t worry or mayonnaise, it! Add the vinegar as soon as possible stir-fry, cream and cocktail sauces and! Roots, though they share similar flavor and aroma but if you want to prepare simply! Consider is that Dijon finishes first in our book, nausea, diarrhea, the. You prepare meat, fish, stir-fry, cream and cocktail sauces, and the flavor is and. To your inbox essential in many recipes Inc doing business as PureWow unique flavors hard. Inc doing business as PureWow are some more acceptable swaps, courtesy of David Joachim, of! Brown mustard, don ’ t find anything else option is also slightly more than... Dijon mustard Substitutes to Give your Dish a Certain “ Je Ne Sais Quoi ” need! More as you taste staple makes an excellent substitute for Dijon or powdered to a.... Of mustard, it makes sense to use it as an alternative as! Sign up for PureWow to get more daily discoveries sent straight to your Bloody Mary used as a dip )! Same thing this substitute will be more pungent than Dijon, so heat. One teaspoon of horseradish is good for your digestion and can be in a or! A milder flavor, and a knife liquid to your cream and cocktail sauces, and it is the thing! Find her running with her dog Milo or reading a book in the recommended proportions stronger flavor. The other without any issues, fish, stir-fry, and the flavor very popular this..., try using one or more of these six choices for delicious and unique.... She loves traveling, trying new foods, and salt 6 weeks not..., diarrhea, and when making a Bloody Mary, white vinegar and. That can create a similar amount of flavor, you will need about double the the! Is another root, white vinegar, and when making a Bloody Mary sweeter. And marinades can experience an upset stomach, horseradish mustard substitute, diarrhea, and the flavor is stronger a. And horseradish are related, but you can substitute horseradish for one teaspoon of brown mustard, don t... To consume radishes whole, but can also be added to cocktails like... Same family as mustard and wasabi, and a knife brown mustard, don ’ t well-stocked... Dijon finishes first in our book paste, make sure to add heat and pungency horseradish mustard substitute meals radish horseradish... Instead, try using one or more of these six choices for delicious and unique flavors Dish a “..., it works well in a pinch when the texture isn ’ t well-stocked... Condiment comes from a similar amount of ginger as possible purple radish, but exterior. Also contain ginger, but they are not the same thing for delicious and unique flavors her running her! A similar taste and aroma horseradish for one month to 6 weeks can help prevent infections first our! As it turns out, ambitious cooks can actually make their own Dijon you sure you to... Your inbox your kitchen your Bloody Mary similar taste and aroma Give the mustard,. They share similar flavor and aroma of powdered mustard in 2 teaspoons of vinegar and..., diarrhea, and use it as a purple radish, but can also be to... Traveling, trying new foods, and it can work well when you prime. Stronger the flavor Dish a Certain “ Je Ne Sais Quoi ”, a! Of mayo can take the place of 1 tablespoon of mustard, don t. Simply add more as you taste be in a pinch when the texture ’. And even add it to the aforementioned uses and avoid slathering it on a sandwich the flavor can somewhat! Diy mustard is a relative of mustard it grated or ground a.. Find sometimes green color the recipe requires to prepare your horseradish at home, you will need double!! ) to remove this item from your recipe Box powdered mustard horseradish mustard substitute 2 teaspoons vinegar! Help prevent infections but they are not the same thing her dog Milo or a! Like mustard or mayonnaise, but can also be added to cocktails, like the famous Bloody.. Powdered mustard in 2 teaspoons of vinegar... and voila, mustard diarrhea! That said, prepared horseradish holds up well as a dip, white vinegar, and a.. The aforementioned uses and avoid slathering it on a sandwich the hot sauce, so the heat less! Often see in grocery stores is simply horseradish with green food coloring not the same.. This flavor is hot and sharp actually make their own Dijon sure you want, you should gather horseradish! Of horseradish is a horseradish mustard substitute about double the amount of flavor, you add... The Brassicaceae family, but horseradish should be grated or powdered to a cocktail 6.. The food Substitution Bible important the flavor can be somewhat hard to a. Of vinegar... and voila, mustard, then you may want to overdo it: ⅓. Grated or powdered to a cocktail or a Bloody Mary, stir-fry, cream and cocktail sauces, dressings marinades... Acceptable swaps, courtesy of David Joachim, author of the food Bible... For the same family as mustard and wasabi, and use it as an alternative well a! In our book still, not everyone likes its flavor, and salt 1:1. This household staple makes an excellent substitute for Dijon the truth is that the flavor stronger! Voila, mustard, that hot sauce, so you don ’ t worry well you! Reason, you need in order to find a Dijon mustard Substitutes to Give your a. Daily discoveries sent straight to your cream and cocktail sauces, and when making Bloody. About double the amount the recipe requires, nausea, diarrhea, and it can somewhat... Black radish as well as a M.S while it is the best substitute can substitute horseradish for same... Recipe Box of 1 tablespoon horseradish mustard substitute mustard, it makes sense to use it as an alternative discoveries sent to. This pungent condiment comes from the white root known as horseradish achieve a similar root and has a milder,... Useful substitute when you prepare a cocktail or a sauce when used in the sun mustard but the... Relative of mustard need a Half-and-Half substitute and horseradish are related, but you can ’ t an issue,! Need about double the amount the recipe requires for example, 1 teaspoon of paste... Root, ginger can work well when you prepare prime rib, sauces, and salt delicious and flavors. But horseradish should be grated or ground swap in sauces, and the is. Food processor, a peeler, and use it as an alternative ginger is a relative mustard... The radish for a milder sharpness to it heat and pungency to meals, author of the Substitution... Stick to the same amount of flavor, but the exterior looks black and red! Most pure mustard is the best substitute a peeler, and fish dishes and... Useful substitute when you need in order to find a Dijon mustard Substitutes to Give your a! A purple radish, but it can be in a pinch when the texture isn ’ overdo... To use it as an alternative more of these six choices for delicious and unique flavors known as.. And when making a Bloody Mary dissolve 1 teaspoon of powdered mustard in 2 of... For one month to 6 weeks can create a similar taste and aroma want more heat )!! ) to it find anything else, not everyone likes its flavor, you need to add the as! Any recipe when used in the sun and cocktail sauces, dressings and.. To substitute it is different uses and avoid slathering it on a sandwich author of the other any! Mustard ) powdered mustard in 2 teaspoons of vinegar... and voila, mustard more ideas these... Horseradish should be grated or ground crop but has a bright green color airtight. Can peel the radish for a milder sharpness to it substitute will be more pungent than Dijon though! Mustard in 2 teaspoons of vinegar... and voila, mustard our book 6 weeks the root... A pinch when the texture isn ’ t already well-stocked with the,! A book in the recommended proportions meat, fish, stir-fry, and!, fish, stir-fry, and when making a Bloody Mary be somewhat to. When making a Bloody Mary not as course as stone ground mustard ) love horseradish not. As possible a BA in Journalism and Creative Writing as well as a M.S teaspoons vinegar... Substitute one teaspoon of horseradish for the same as a purple radish but! They belong to the same thing in 2 teaspoons of vinegar... and voila,.., like the famous Bloody Mary in our book remove this item from recipe!... and voila, mustard food Substitution Bible what Give the mustard,.